I rated 4 stars (rather than 3) to give the benefit of the doubt and not let my personal preferences influence the rating too much. Flavor reminds me of chewing gum -- pleasant, not artificial or overly minty. Pouches are beefy and feel like small pillows; I prefer the slimline shape of the old Whitetail pouches. Nicotine content is supposed to be 6mg, though I don't really feel any kick even with two pouches (maybe because I'm used to relative high levels of nicotine with Whitetail Black chew). I like the fact that the ingredients are natural (stone ground corn) vs. whatever is in the rest of the pouches out there.

Love the bite they leak a bit

All in all, I really enjoyed them, what I love most is everything is natural and not synthetic. THEY'RE REAL ! However I did notice some inconsistency in some of the pouches… some hitting smooth and natural, others that seemed like they were just duds, just a mint pouch in my mouth, no hit at all. That’s the only constructive criticism I have.
I will definitely still be buying them, and also hoping for better consistency. Thank you guys for what you’re doing. Still a 5 out of 5 for me ! Anyone reading this that is unsure, BUY some and enjoy !!

I like the size and the moisture of the pouches. I would like to see a lot more sweetener in there. The Wintergreen can be a little overpowering. Also wish there was something stronger than 6mg.

Decent pouch and I commend the team for trying something new (especially a more natural approach). Flavor is great, feels low impact, it’s a good experience. There’s a lot of loose grit in the can, and the pouches themselves are a bit large and loose. Flavor doesn’t last quite as long as I’d like. That said, while there’s some room for improvement, these are decent pouches.